Skip to main content

ELTRG Seminar: Jorge Luis Fabra-Zamora (University of Buffalo) - ‘The Legality of Sports and Leagues Reconsidered’

photo

Location:

Moot Court Room,
Old College

Date/time

Thu 23 January 2025
15:00-17:00

This is a seminar organised by the Edinburgh Legal Theory Research Group. The speaker Jorge Luis Fabra-Zamora, from University of Buffalo, will be presenting his paper on ‘The Legality of Sports and Leagues Reconsidered’.

Our seminars consist of a 30-minute presentation given by the author, followed by a 60 to 90-minute Q&A. This is not a pre-read event, but the paper will be circulated beforehand through our mailing list. To subscribe, please send an email to edinburgh.legal.theory@gmail.com.

Author bio: Jorge Luis Fabra-Zamora is Associate Professor of Law at University of Buffalo. His research interests include Legal Theory, Jurisprudence, Torts, Globalization, International Human Rights Law, and Transitional Justice.

Abstract: Many writers in the flourishing field of the jurisprudence of sports argue that sports and leagues are types of law. This article critically examines this view. The argument begins with a criticism of standard arguments supporting such a position that I name the linguistic and systematic arguments. Then, I outline a novel account of practice-based normative phenomena, which draws on my liberal interpretation of some central themes of theories of analytical jurisprudence. My account includes a novel account of the distinctiveness of law, which restricts the domain of law to those normative orders constituting political communities—namely, large-scale norm-created groups that regulate important politico-moral issues through the exercise of strong forms of social pressure. With this view at hand, I reject the view that sports’ normative orders are best conceived as legal orders while recognizing the legal character of some leagues such as FIFA.
 

Event Link

Register to attend in person

Share