School of Law School of Law
Academic Staff    
Professor Neil Walker
Professor of Public Law and the Law of Nature and Nations
LLB, PhD


School of Law
University of Edinburgh
Old College
South Bridge
Edinburgh EH8 9YL
UK

Tel: 0131 650 2353
Fax: 0131 650 6317
Email: neil.walker@ed.ac.uk
SSRN: View Papers
Biographical Details
Neil Walker holds the Regius Chair of Public Law and the Law of Nature and Nations at the University of Edinburgh.

His main area of expertise is constitutional theory. He has published extensively on the constitutional dimension of legal order at sub-state, state, supranational and international levels. He has also published at length on the relationship between security, legal order and political community. He maintains a more general interest in broader questions of legal theory as well as in various substantive dimensions of UK and EU public law.
Previously he taught public law at Edinburgh for ten years (1986-96), was Professor of Legal and Constitutional Theory at the University of Aberdeen (1996-2000), and, most recently, was Professor of European Law at the European University Institute in Florence (2000-8), where he was also the first Dean of Studies (2002-5).
He has also held various visiting appointments - including Visiting Professor, Department of Philosophy, University of Tilburg, Netherlands (2000); Visiting Professor of Law, University of Columbia, NY(2005); Eugene Einaudi Chair of European Studies, University of Cornell (2007); and Distinguished Visiting Professor of Law, University of Toronto (2007).
Professor Walker's inaugural lecture, entitled "Out of Place and Out of Time: Law's Fading Co-ordinates", was delivered on the 18th November 2008. You can listen to it from the Blogs and Podcasts section of the School website.
In December 2008 Professor Walker was asked by the Scottish Government to conduct an independent review of final appellate jurisdiction in the Scottish legal system. His final Report, submitted in January 2010, can be found at:
Courses Taught
Law, Democracy and Citizenship (Honours) (Course Organiser)
EU Constitutional Law (LLM)
Global Crime, Justice and Security in Context (LLM)
Legal Research Methods (LLM)
Theories and Philosophies of Legal Research (LLM)
Traditions of Legal Enquiry (LLM)
Jurisprudence (Ordinary) (Course Organiser)
European Lawyers Programme (Others)
PhD Supervisees
Ross Carrick  'The European Court of Justice as a Democratic Forum'
Conrado Hübner Mendes  'Deliberative performance of constitutional courts'
Oche Onazi  'Towards legal and institutional frameworks for the democratisation of public goods'
Ioannis Papageorgiou  'Political culture and prison privatization'
Paolo Sandro  '‘Administrative moment’ and judicial protection: outline of a general framework'
Stephen Thomson  'Judicial review in its Scottish constitutional context'
Kai Tu  'Constitutional Law of Peoples: P R China and Peripheries'
Yi You  'Crime and Punishment in Social Theories'
Selected Publications
Books
Neil Walker, Ian Loader Civilizing Security (Cambridge University Press, 2007)
Synopsis
This book develops and defends an original argument concerning the importance and value of security as a good, and the virtue and necessity of the democratic state in fostering and sustaining that good. It travels widely over debates in social and political theory, sociology, criminology, law and international security studies.
Neil Walker Policing in a Changing Constitutional Order (Sweet & Maxwell, 2000)
Bill GilmoreNeil Walker, Malcolm Anderson, Monica den Boer, Peter Cullen, and Charles D. Raab Policing the European Union (Clarendon Press, 1996)
Synopsis
International co-operation and criminal law enforcement have become a centrally important policy issue for Europe in the 1990s. This book examines all of the major empirical and theoretical issues associated with the emerging pattern of co-operation, including the harmonization of criminal law and criminal procedures, law enforcement strategies, police organization and discipline, and the politics of immigration and civil liberties.
Chris HimsworthNeil Walker The Scottish Community Charge (W Green and Son, Edinburgh, 1989)
Neil Walker, D Bradley and R Wilkie Managing the Police: Law, Organisation and Democracy (Wheatsheaf Books, Harvester Press, Brighton, 1986)
Edited Books
Neil Walker, Gianluigi Palombella Relocating the Rule of Law (Hart, 2009)
Neil Walker, Martin Loughlin The Paradox of Constitutionalism (Oxford University Press, 2007)
Synopsis
This book sets out to examine some of the key features of what we describe as the paradox of constitutionalism: whether those who have the authority to make a constitution - the 'constituent power' - can do so without effectively surrendering that authority to the institutional sites of power 'constituted' by the constitutional form they enact. In particular, is the constituent power exhausted in the single constitutive act or does it retain a presence, acting as critical check on the constitutional operating system and/or an alternative source of authority to be invoked in moments of crisis? These questions have been debated both in different national contexts and at the level of constitutional theory, and these debates are acknowledged and developed in the first two sections of the book.

Part I includes chapters on how the question of constituent power has been treated in the constitutional histories of USA, France, UK and Germany, while Part II examines at the question of constituent power from the perspective of both liberal and non-liberal theories of the state and legal order. The essays in Part III consider the operation of constitutionalism with respect to a series of contemporary challenges to the state, including those from popular movements below the level of the state and challenges from the supranational and international levels, and they analyse how the puzzles associated with the question of constituent power are played out in these increasingly important settings

Neil Walker Relocating Sovereignty (Ashgate, 2006)
Synopsis
This volume brings together a collection of classic and contemporary texts which engage with the core problem of sovereignty from the perspective of various legal and law-related sub-disciplines: legal history and theory, constitutional law, international law and relations and EU law. Many of the highlights from the intense debates about the continuing relevance or otherwise of the internal sovereignty of national legal orders and the external sovereignty of states in a rapidly- globalizing world are reproduced here.
Neil Walker Europe's Area of Freedom, Security, and Justice (Oxford University Press, 2004)
Synopsis
This collection brings together leading specialists in the areas of European Union law which are now organized under the Area of Freedom, Security and Justice (AFSJ). The concept of the AFSJ was introduced into the EU Treaty framework by the Treaty of Amsterdam in 1997, and it incorporates migration law, family reunion law, asylum law, police cooperation, and cooperation in criminal law. Each of these areas of law is the subject of an in-depth examination in a separate chapter of this book.
The early years of the AFSJ, building upon a substantial body of law already in place under the Treaty of Maastricht and various intergovernmental arrangements, have witnessed a rapid expansion in legislative and executive activity in the field of European internal security. In migration law, family reunion law, asylum law, police co-operation, and co-operation in criminal law, the scale and intensity of action at the supranational level is already such as to overturn longstanding assumptions about the priority of national law in matters of migration control and criminal justice.

An introductory chapter examines the various policy strands covered by the AFSJ; investigates what, if anything, can be viewed as its distinctive legal underpinning; and discusses its possible future development in the light of current discussions over the adoption of a first documentary Constitution for the European Union. In addition to setting out the main contours of legal policy, each chapter examines the continuing tension between national sovereignty on the one hand and a growing commitment to collective, EU-wide action on the other. The volume also addresses the wider constitutional implications of a growing supranational capacity in questions of the priority of political values in the evolving EU; fundamental rights protection; the control of new forms of executive and administrative discretion; and the pressures of accommodating the ten new Enlargement states within the internal security field.
Neil Walker Sovereignty in Transition (Hart Publishing, 2003)
Neil Walker, Paul Beaumont and Carole Lyons Convergence and Divergence in European Public Law (Hart Publishing, 2002)
Neil Walker, Paul Beaumont Legal Framework of the European Single Currency (Hart Publishing, 1999)
Neil WalkerChris Himsworth, Wilson Finnie Edinburgh Essays in Public Law (Edinburgh University Press, 1991)
Journal Articles
Neil Walker 'Out of Place and Out of Time: Law's Fading Co-ordinates' (2010) Edinburgh Law Review 13-46 Vol. 14
Neil Walker 'The Anti-Political Polity' (2010) Modern Law Review 73 141-154
Neil Walker 'Europe at 50. A Midlife Crisis. Democratic Deficit and Sovereignty surplus' (2008) Irish Journal of European Law 23-34 Vol 15(3 and 4)
Neil Walker 'Beyond boundary disputes and basic grids: Mapping the global disorder of normative orders' (2008) International Journal of Constitutional Law Vol. 6 pp.373-96
Neil Walker 'Taking Constitutionalism Beyond the State' (2008) Political Studies vol. 56 pp.519-543
View this ArticleView this Article
Neil Walker 'Not the European Constitution' (2008) Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law Vol 15 no 1
Neil Walker 'Juridical Transformation as a Process: A Comment on Stone Sweet' (2007) German Law Journal Vol. 10 (October 2007)
Neil Walker 'EU Constitutionalism in the State Constitutional Tradition' (2007) Current Legal Problems
Neil Walker 'A Constitutional Reckoning' (2006) Constellations Vol. 13(2): 140-150
Neil Walker 'Legal Theory and the European Union: A 25th Anniversary Essay' (2005) Oxford Journal of Legal Studies vol.25 581-601
Neil Walker 'Europe’s Constitutional Engagement' (2005) Ratio Juris 18: 387-399
Neil Walker 'Europe’s Constitutional Momentum and the Search for Polity Legitimacy' (2005) International Journal of Constitutional Law Vol. 4(2): 211-238
Neil Walker 'A State of Denial?: Rethinking the Governance of Security' (2004) Punishment & Society Vol. 6: 221-8
Neil Walker 'The Legacy of Europe’s Constitutional Moment' (2004) Constellations Vol. 11(3): 368-392
Neil Walker 'Constitutionalising Enlargement, Enlarging Constitutionalism' (2003) European Law Journal Vol. 9 No. 3: 365-385
Neil Walker, G de Burca 'Law and Transnational Civil Society: Upsetting the Agenda?' (2003) European Law Journal Vol. 9 No. 4: 387-400
Neil Walker 'Europe's Constitutional Passion Play' (2003) European Law Review Vol. 28(6): 905-908
Neil Walker 'Policing and the Supranational' (2002) Policing and Society Vol. 12 (Autumn): 307-321
Neil Walker 'The Idea of Constitutional Pluralism' (2002) Modern Law Review Vol. 65(3): 317-359
Abstract
Constitutional discourse has perhaps never been more popular, nor more comprehensively challenged than it is today. The development of new constitutional settlements and languages at state and post-state level has to be balanced against the deepening of a formidable range of sceptical attitudes. These include the claim that constitutionalism remains too state-centered, overstates its capacity to shape political community, exhibits an inherent normative bias against social developments associated with the politics of difference, provides a language easily susceptible to ideological manipulation and, that, consequent upon these challenges, it increasingly represents a fractured and debased conceptual currency. A rehabilitated language of constitutionalism would meet these challenges through a version of constitutional pluralism. Constitutional pluralism recognises that in the post-Westphalian world there exists a range of different constitutional sites and processes configured in a heterarchical rather than a hierarchical pattern, and seeks to develop a number of empirical indices and normative criteria which allow us to understand this emerging configuration and assess the legitimacy of its development.
Neil Walker 'All Dressed Up' (2001) Oxford Journal of Legal Studies Vol. 21: 563-582
Neil Walker, Ian Loader 'Policing as a Public Good: Reconstituting the Connections Between Policing and the State’' (2001) Theoretical Criminology Vol. 5: 9-35
Neil Walker 'Setting English Judges to Rights' (1999) Oxford Journal of Legal Studies Vol. 19(1): 133-151
Neil Walker 'Justice and Home Affairs' (1998) International and Comparative Law Quarterly Vol. 47 Part 1, pp.231-238
Neil Walker 'Defining Core Police Tasks: The Neglect of the Symbolic Dimension?' (1996) Policing and Society Vol. 6: 53-71
Neil Walker 'Law Under Pressure' (1994) Modern Law Review Vol. 47: 130-150
Neil Walker 'The Accountability of European Policing Institutions' (1993) European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research Vol. 1(4): 34-52
Neil Walker 'European Policing After 1992' (1993) Journal of Common Market Studies Vol. 31(1): 3-28
Chris Himsworth, Neil Walker 'The Poll Tax and Fundamental Law' (1991) Juridical Review Spring, pp.45-78
Neil Walker 'Spycatcher’s Scottish Sequel' (1990) Public Law pp. 354-371
Chris Himsworth, Neil Walker 'Where Rates and Charges Meet' (1989) Juridical Review pp. 189-195
Chris Himsworth, Neil Walker 'After Rates? The Community Charge in Scotland' (1987) Public Law pp. 586-616
Neil Walker, D Bradley and R Wilkie 'Beyond Managing by Objectives' (1987) Policing Vol. 3(1): 68-74
Chapters
Neil Walker 'Denizenship and Deterritorialization in the European Union' in Hans Lindahl (eds) A right to Inclusion and exclusion? (Hart, 2009) 261-272
Neil Walker 'Reframing EU Constitutionalism' in Jeffrey Dunoff and Joel Trachtman (eds) Ruling the World? Constitutionalism, International Law and Global Governance (Cambridge, 2009) 149-177
Neil Walker 'The Variety of Sovereignty' in Rebecca Adler-Nissen and Thomas Gammeltoft-Hansen (eds) Sovereignty Games: Instrumentalizing State Sovereignty in Europe and Beyond (Palgrave, 2009) 21-32
Neil Walker 'The Rule of Law and the EU: Necessity's Mixed Virtue' in Neil Walker, Gianluigi Palombella (eds) Relocating the Rule of Law (Hart, 2009) 119-138
Neil Walker, Ian Loader 'Liberty, Security and the Responsible State' in Stuart White and Daniel Leighton (eds) Building a Citizen Society (Lawrence and Wishart, 2008) 44-56
Neil Walker 'The pattern of transnational policing' in Tim Newburn (eds) Handbook of Policing (2nd Edition) (Willan Publishing, 2008)
Neil Walker 'The reframing of law's imperial frame: A comment on Tully' in Stephen Tierney, Emilios Christodoulidis (eds) Public Law and Politics (Ashgate, 2008)
Neil Walker 'Making a World of Difference? Habermas, Cosmopolitanism and the Constitutionalization of International Law' in O. Payrow Shabani (eds) Multiculturalism and Law: A Critical Debate (University of Wales Press, 2007) pp.219-234
Neil Walker 'The Migration of Constitutional ideas and the Migration of the Constitutional Idea' in S. Choudhry (eds) The Migration of Constitutional Ideas (Cambridge University Press, 2007) pp. 316-344
Neil Walker, Ian Loader 'Locating the Public Interest in Transnational Policing' in Andrew Goldsmith and James Sheptycki (eds) Crafting Transnational Policing (Hart Publishing, 2007) pp.111-146
Neil Walker, M. Loughlin 'Introduction' in Neil Walker, Martin Loughlin (eds) The Paradox of Constitutionalism (Oxford University Press, 2007) pp. 1-8
Neil Walker 'Post-Constituent Constitutionalism' in Neil Walker, Martin Loughlin (eds) The Paradox of Constitutionalism (Oxford University Press, 2007) pp.247-268
Neil Walker 'On Regulating the Regulation of Regulation' in F. Cafaggi (eds) Reframing Self-regulation in European Private Law (Kluwer, 2006) pp. 347-357
Neil Walker, Ian Loader 'Necessary Virtues: The Legitimate Place of the State in the Production of Security' in Jennifer Wood and Benoît Dupont (eds) Democracy, Security and the Governance of Society (Cambridge University Press, 2006) pp.165-195
Neil Walker 'The Burden of Universalism' in Zenon Bankowski, James MacLean (eds) The Universal and the Particular in Legal Reasoning (Ashgate, 2006) pp.53-68
Neil Walker 'EU Constitutionalism and New Governance' in G. De Burca and J. Scott (eds) Constitutionalism and New Governance in Europe and United States (Hart Publishing, 2006) pp. 15-36
Neil Walker 'Relocating Sovereignty: An Introduction' in Neil Walker Relocating Sovereignty (Ashgate, 2006)
Neil Walker 'Central Europe’s Second Constitutional Transition: The EU Accession Phase' in A. Czarnota, M. Krygier and W. Sadurski (eds) Rethinking the Rule of Law After Communism (Central European University Press, 2005) pp. 341-370
Neil Walker 'Sovereignty, Global Security and the Regulation of Armed Conflict: The Possibilities of Political Agency' in J. Huysmans, A. Dobson and R. Prokhovnik (eds) The Politics of Protection: Sites of Security and Political Agency (Routledge, 2005) pp.154-174
Neil Walker 'In Search of the Area of Freedom, Security and Justice: A Constitutional Odyssey' in Neil Walker Europe's Area of Freedom, Security, and Justice (Oxford University Press, 2004) pp.3-40
Neil Walker 'Postnational Constitutionalism and the Problem of Translation' in J.H.H. Weiler and M. Wind (eds) European Constitutionalism Beyond the State (Cambridge University Press, 2003) pp.27-54
Neil Walker 'Late Sovereignty in the European Union' in Neil Walker Sovereignty in Transition (Hart Publishing, 2003) pp. 3-32
Neil Walker 'Culture, Democracy and the Convergence of Public Law: Some Scepticisms about Scepticism' in Neil Walker, Paul Beaumont and Carole Lyons (eds) Convergence and Divergence in European Public Law (Hart Publishing, 2002) pp. 257-272
Neil Walker 'The Problem of Trust in an Enlarged Area of Freedom, Security and Justice: A Conceptual Analysis' in M. Anderson and J. Apap (eds) Police and Justice Co-operation and the New European Borders (Kluwer Law International, 2002) pp. 19-34
Neil Walker 'Human Rights and Postnationality: Reconciling Political and Constitutional Pluralism' in Tom Campbell, Keith Ewing, and Adam Tomkins (eds) Sceptical Essays on Human Rights (Oxford University Press, 2001) pp. 119-144
Neil Walker 'Fundamental Law' in (eds) Stair Memorial Encyclopaedia of the Laws of Scotland (Re-issue 4) (Butterworths Law (Scotland), 2001) Volume on Constitutional Law, pp. 29-82
Neil Walker 'The Transnational Dimension' in F. Leishman, B. Loveday and S. P. Savage (eds) Core Issues in Policing (Longman, 2000)
Neil Walker 'The Antinomies of the Law Officers' in M Sunkin and S Payne (eds) The Nature of the Crown: A Legal and Political Analysis (Oxford University Press, 1999) pp.135-164
Neil Walker 'Situating Scottish Policing' in Peter Duff and Neil Hutton (eds) Criminal Justice in Scotland (Ashgate, 1999) pp.94-114
Neil Walker 'The New Frontiers of European Policing' in Malcolm Anderson, Eberhard Bort (eds) The Frontiers of Europe (Pinter, 1998) pp.165-186
Neil Walker 'Deficient Weaponry, Reluctant Marksmen and Obscure Targets: Flaws in the Accountability of Undercover Policing in the EU' in den Boer, M. (eds) Undercover Policing and Accountability from an International Perspective (European Institute of Public Administration, Maastricht, 1997) pp.205-216
Neil Walker 'The Crumbling Pillars of Statutory Interpretation' in Hector MacQueen Scots Law into the 21st Century: Essays in Honour of W. A. Wilson (W. Green / Sweet & Maxwell, 1996) pp. 126-137
Neil Walker 'Policing the European Union: The Politics of Transition' in O. Marenin (eds) Policing Change, Changing Police: International Perspectives (Garland Publishing Inc, US, 1995) pp.251-284
Neil Walker 'Care and Control in the Police Organisation' in M. Stephens and S. Becker (eds) Police Force, Police Service: Care and Control in Britain (Palgrave Macmillan, 1994) pp.33-66
Neil Walker 'European Integration and European Policing: A Complex Relationship' in M Anderson and M Den Boer (eds) Policing Across National Boundaries (London: Pinter, 1994) pp.22-45
Neil Walker 'The International Dimension' in R Reiner and S Spencer (eds) Accountable Policing: Empowerment, Effectiveness and Equity (Institute for Public Policy Research, 1993) pp. 113-171
Neil Walker 'The Middle Ground in Public Law' in Neil Walker, Chris Himsworth, Wilson Finnie (eds) Edinburgh Essays in Public Law (Edinburgh University Press, 1991) pp. 57-95
Notes and Reviews
Neil Walker 'Big “C” or small “c”?' (2006) European Law Journal Vol. 12, pp.12-14
Abstract
(Note: Italian version “Una costituzione con la “C” maiuscola o con la “c” minuscola?” published in (2005) 25 Quaderni costituzionali 881-884.)
Working and Occasional Papers
Neil Walker 'Beyond the Holistic Constitution?', School of Law Working Paper Series, 2009/16 (SSRN, 2009)
View this ArticleView this Article

Abstract
This paper considers whether, why and to what extent we should conceive of transnational regulation in constitutional terms. It distinguishes between two different candidates for transnational constitutional status. On the one hand, there are various actual or potential 'holistic' transnational constitutions, such as the EU and the WTO. These constitutional orders resembe that of the state to the extent that they involve the framing of a distinct 'body politic'. This 'body politic' may be thinner or thicker, depending on the number and richness of the framing layers involved (legal order, politico-institutional complex, popular self-authorization, distinct society or demos), but the idea of the constitution as a constituent dimension and expression of a broadly encompassing, internally coherent and externally bounded polity is present in all cases. On the other hand, there are also today various international societal actors and functional spheres (e.g internet regulation, sport regulation) that on one view possess their own 'societal constitutions'. Unlike holistic forms of regulation, however, these areas tend to combine very narrow forms of self-regulation with diverse forms of external regulation. The idea of a discrete framing is not present even in legal or institutional terms, still less in popular or social terms. Nevertheless, the paper argues, there may be good normative reasons for continuing to use the language and mindset of constitutionalism in these contexts.
Neil Walker 'Out of Place and Out of Time: Law's Fading Co-Ordinates', School of Law Working Paper Series, 2009/01 (SSRN, 2009)
View this ArticleView this Article

Abstract
Modern jurisprudence has been dominated by questions of authority and questions of meaning. The present paper addresses what it calls the third question of jurisprudence - namely the question of how law situates itself in space and time. This is a question to be addressed at various levels, the most important of which concerns the overall legitimacy of law as a normative enterprise which claims to come from somewhere and 'somewhen' and to be directed to somewhere and 'somewhen'. In the Westphalian tradition in which the dominant forms of law have been constitutional law and international law, this question of self-situation has tended to be answered either in highly universalistic terms (a law that transcended place and time) or in highly particularistic terms (a law that was peculiar to a particular place and perpetual in its ambition) . Both universalistic and particularistic narratives, despite their superficial contrast, emphasize the holistic and magisterial properties of law - as a form of authority that is both comprehensive and self-contained and sovereign within its situation. Today, with the fading of the Westphalian paradigm and the growth of myriad new forms of transnational law, various forms of new regulation - pluri-constitutive, interstitial, non-constitutive and global general law - lack the background co-ordinates either of universalism or of a comprehensive particularism and the associated systemic qualities of holism and magisterialism. What do these new forms of 'uncharted law' suggest more generally about the future of the legal form and of the ways in which law may legitimate itself?
Neil Walker 'Denizenship and the Deterritorialization in the EU', EUI Working Papers Law, EUI LAW 2008/08 (European University Institute, 2008)
View this ArticleView this Article

Abstract
The category of the denizen is becoming increasingly important in the identity politics of the EU. EU law and policy over a number of years has encouraged the development of a new hybrid status of the permanent resident who possesses many legal and social rights but lacks full political citizenship. Thinkers and politicians differ over the implications of this development, some seeing it as a temporary status on the way to full citizenship, others seeing it as a permanent sub-citizenship status, and others still seeing it as a way of moving beyond the citizenship/non-citizenship dichotomy in understanding the relationship between individuals and political communities. The paper explores this third alternative at some length, and concludes that the figure of the denizen may indeed be an appropriate archetype for imagining political community at the supranational level.

Accessibility menu