School of Law School of Law
Scots Law News    
scales Scots Law News
 Search SLN
Hector L MacQueen and Scott Wortley
email:hector.macqueen@ed.ac.uk
latest posts by Hector MacQueen in this blog:





Sound and fury in Washington
21 July 2010 06:33

David Cameron, the British Prime Minister, and Barack Obama, the US President, are in "violent agreement" that last year's compassionate release of the convicted Lockerbie bomber by the Scottish Justice Secretary was a mistake.

The curious phrase - did Cameron and Obama perhaps have an arm wrestle in which neither was able to gain the advantage, or something even more serious? - was uttered by the Prime Minister during a joint press conference with the President after their summit meeting in Washington DC on 20 July 2010.

Mr Cameron has apparently committed to a review of UK Government papers relating to the UK-Libya deal in 2007 (for which BP admittedly lobbied) to be carried out by the UK Cabinet Secretary, while President Obama will not press for the full inquiry sought by four US Senators and Secretary of State Hillary Clinton.   But since Mr Cameron apparently knows already that the Megrahi release was not BP's fault, the review seems most unlikely to offer new insights into the whole matter.

The conjunction of BP's unpopularity in the USA after the Deepwater Horizon oilspill, Cameron's Washington visit, the approach of mid-term elections to the US Senate in November while Obama's approval ratings slump, and of course Megrahi's continued survival, has led to this early revival of the story (Scots Law News had thought it would probably hot up nearer the anniversary of the release).  The projected inquiry on 29 July by the US Senate Foreign Relations Committee should now keep it going a while longer.

Words from the Scottish play come irresistibly to mind:

It is a tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.

 

Comments:
Please note, you must be logged in with your EASE account to post comments. Click here to login
Please also note that you can change your nickname at any time, but only once every six months.
If you don't have an EASE account, you can click here to register as an EASE friend
Ross
22/07/2010 19:40:58
The release of Megrahi was a Scottish issue, regulated by Scottish rules of law and decided by the Scottish Government. The Obama Administration has some cheek in demanding an inquiry into, and information on, this decision; making the demand to not-the-Scottish-Government; and publicly stating that the Scottish Government should 'learn' from this 'wrong decision'!
Mark
26/07/2010 16:43:47
It seems clear from the news coverage that the Obama administration was tasked with the keeping the political damage at a minimum to the voters horrified at the one person convicted of the bombing and recognizing the authority of the Scottish Parliament. Leaked documents seem to show the Obama administration preferred compassionate release over prisoner transfer. Doubt this is the latest we will hear about this as long as Mr. Megrahi remains alive.
le roi des voleurs
26/07/2010 17:50:54
The fact that the US Administration may have preferred the compassionate grounds over the prisoner transfer idea is brilliant. The US anger seems to be growing in direct porportion to the length of time Megrahi survives. It is ever so slightly more acceptable for him to be released on compassionate grounds.....as long as he dies soon(ish)?

The Sheridan Trial - updates and analysis from the perjury trial of Tommy and Gail Sheridan and its aftermath

Absolvitor (Scots law magazine)

Case Check (Scots law case reports, articles, etc)

Devolution Matters (blog on devolution questions and politics across the UK, by Alan Trench)

A Diary of Injustice in Scotland (by Peter Cerbi)

Edinburgh Law School Blawgs

The Firm (Scots law magazine)

Gavin Ward's Scots Law Blawg (commentary on Scots law)

Ian Hamilton QC (a drunk man looks at the thistle)

Land Matters (occasional thoughts and comments on land issues and other stuff by Andy Wightman)

Legaleaglemhm (diary of a Glasgow Diploma student)

Life of a Scots Law Student (at Stirling)

The Lockerbie Case Blog (by Professor Robert Black)

Jennie Law (by a self-styled "Library Monkey" from a law firm in Edinburgh)

Jonathan Mitchell QC (self-explanatory)

Journal Online (Journal of the Law Society of Scotland)

Lallands Peat Worrier (Nationalist blogger with an interest in human rights law)

Outlaw.com

panGloss (IT with Professor Lilian Edwards)

Ramblings of a Scottish Student (studying law at Stirling University)

Scots Law Student (life and trials of learning law in Scotland)

Scottish Human Rights Law Group (formed in 2009)

Scottish Law Reporter (self-explanatory)

Technollama (IT with Andres Guadamuz of Edinburgh Law School)

UKSC (a blog on the doings of the UK Supreme Court)

Accessibility menu